The Powerful Weapon of Ambiguity

Fouad Ajami on what is odd about Obama and his crowds:

There is something odd — and dare I say novel — in American politics about the crowds that have been greeting Barack Obama on his campaign trail. Hitherto, crowds have not been a prominent feature of American politics. We associate them with the temper of Third World societies. We think of places like Argentina and Egypt and Iran, of multitudes brought together by their zeal for a Peron or a Nasser or a Khomeini. In these kinds of societies, the crowd comes forth to affirm its faith in a redeemer: a man who would set the world right.

…These crowds, in the tens of thousands, who have been turning out for the Democratic standard-bearer in St. Louis and Denver and Portland, are a measure of American distress.

On the face of it, there is nothing overwhelmingly stirring about Sen. Obama. There is a cerebral quality to him, and an air of detachment. He has eloquence, but within bounds. After nearly two years on the trail, the audience can pretty much anticipate and recite his lines. The political genius of the man is that he is a blank slate. The devotees can project onto him what they wish. The coalition that has propelled his quest — African-Americans and affluent white liberals — has no economic coherence. But for the moment, there is the illusion of a common undertaking …. The day after, the crowd will of course discover its own fissures. The affluent will have to pay for the programs promised the poor. The redistribution agenda that runs through Mr. Obama’s vision is anathema to the Silicon Valley entrepreneurs and the hedge-fund managers now smitten with him. Their ethos is one of competition and the justice of the rewards that come with risk and effort. All this is shelved, as the devotees sustain the candidacy of a man whose public career has been a steady advocacy of reining in the market and organizing those who believe in entitlement and redistribution.

A creature of universities and churches and nonprofit institutions, the Illinois senator, with the blessing and acquiescence of his upscale supporters, has glided past these hard distinctions. On the face of it, it must be surmised that his affluent devotees are ready to foot the bill for the new order, or are convinced that after victory the old ways will endure, and that Mr. Obama will govern from the center. Ambiguity has been a powerful weapon of this gifted candidate: He has been different things to different people, and he was under no obligation to tell this coalition of a thousand discontents, and a thousand visions, the details of his political programs: redistribution for the poor, postracial absolution and “modernity” for the upper end of the scale.

It was no accident that the white working class was the last segment of the population to sign up for the Obama journey. Their hesitancy was not about race. They were men and women of practicality; they distrusted oratory, they could see through the falseness of the solidarity offered by this campaign. They did not have much, but believed in the legitimacy of what little they had acquired. They valued work and its rewards. They knew and heard of staggering wealth made by the Masters of the Universe, but held onto their faith in the outcomes that economic life decreed. The economic hurricane that struck America some weeks ago shook them to the core. They now seek protection, the shelter of the state, and the promise of social repair. The bonuses of the wizards who ran the great corporate entities had not bothered them. It was the spectacle of the work of the wizards melting before our eyes that unsettled them.

Daniel Patrick Moynihan, the late Democratic senator from New York, once set the difference between American capitalism and the older European version by observing that America was the party of liberty, whereas Europe was the party of equality. Just in the nick of time for the Obama candidacy, the American faith in liberty began to crack. The preachers of America’s decline in the global pecking order had added to the panic. Our best days were behind us, the declinists prophesied. The sun was setting on our imperium, and rising in other lands.

A younger man, “cool” and collected, carrying within his own biography the strands of the world beyond America’s shores, was put forth as a herald of the change upon us. The crowd would risk the experiment. There was grudge and a desire for retribution in the crowd to begin with. Akin to the passions that have shaped and driven highly polarized societies, this election has at its core a desire to settle the unfinished account of the presidential election eight years ago. George W. Bush’s presidency remained, for his countless critics and detractors, a tale of usurpation. He had gotten what was not his due; more galling still, he had been bold and unabashed, and taken his time at the helm as an opportunity to assert an ambitious doctrine of American power abroad. He had waged a war of choice in Iraq.

This election is the rematch that John Kerry had not delivered on. In the fashion of the crowd that seeks and sees the justice of retribution, Mr. Obama’s supporters have been willing to overlook his means. So a candidate pledged to good government and to ending the role of money in our political life opts out of public financing of presidential campaigns. What of it? The end justifies the means.

Save in times of national peril, Americans have been sober, really minimalist, in what they expected out of national elections, out of politics itself. The outcomes that mattered were decided in the push and pull of daily life, by the inventors and the entrepreneurs, and the captains of industry and finance. To be sure, there was a measure of willfulness in this national vision, for politics and wars guided the destiny of this republic. But that American sobriety and skepticism about politics — and leaders — set this republic apart from political cultures that saw redemption lurking around every corner.

My boyhood, and the Arab political culture I have been chronicling for well over three decades, are anchored in the Arab world. And the tragedy of Arab political culture has been the unending expectation of the crowd — the street, we call it — in the redeemer who will put an end to the decline, who will restore faded splendor and greatness. When I came into my own, in the late 1950s and ’60s, those hopes were invested in the Egyptian Gamal Abdul Nasser. He faltered, and broke the hearts of generations of Arabs. But the faith in the Awaited One lives on, and it would forever circle the Arab world looking for the next redeemer.

America is a different land, for me exceptional in all the ways that matter. In recent days, those vast Obama crowds, though, have recalled for me the politics of charisma that wrecked Arab and Muslim societies. A leader does not have to say much, or be much. The crowd is left to its most powerful possession — its imagination…

Victor Davis Hanson on why America is in better shape to weather the financial crisis than any other country.

And this interesting excerpt:

…the war in Iraq is no longer even a war in a traditional sense. Four times as many Americans were murdered just in the city of Chicago at peace in July than all those Americans who were killed in Iraq at war in the same period.

Mark Steyn on Barry’s Aunt Zeituni:

The London Times story of Barack Obama’s Aunt Zeituni – like that of his penniless brother and the Kenyan grade school he promised to help – is interesting not only as a reflection on the candidate’s belief that “spreading the wealth around” is a centralized government mandate to be imposed on Joe the Plumber rather than a personal act by, say, a wealthy memoirist whose books repackage colorful relatives to highly lucrative effect.

But, aside from all that, this detail is lovely:

“The Times could not determine their immigration status and an official at Boston City Hall said that Ms Onyango was a resident of Flaherty Way but not registered to vote on the electoral roll. However, that Ms Onyango made a contribution to the Obama campaign would indicate that she is a US citizen.”

Of course. By definition, if you donate to Barack the Good, you must be one of his loyal subjects. They should make it a requirement of the citizenship test.

By the way, the argument that giving money to Obama is ipso facto proof of citizenship also clears up any question marks over those donations by “A Hitler” and “S Hussein”. Congratulations!

Oh, and if you want to know why The Boston Globe’s parent company ( The New York Times) has been downgraded by Moody’s to junk status, ask yourself why this story is in a foreign newspaper three thousand miles away rather than the local rag.

1 Tadalafil Cialis
Cialis Opposite Effec
Search Viagra Edinburgh Find Pages
Before Cialis
Viagra Generic
Cheap Drug Retin Tramadol Viagra
Generic Viagra Mastercard
Frequent Use Viagra
Viagra Energy Drink
Viagra Patent Number
Generic Viagra Pill
5sildenafil Cialis Generico
Identify Real Cialis
Male Depression Sri Viagra Libido
Funny Viagra Pictures
Cialis Generic Softtabs
Adam Natural Viagra
Viagra Lowest
Taking Viagra Woman
Cialis Cheapest Price
Edinburgh Viagra Find Order Search
Generic Cialis Pills Canada
Viagra Discounts
Cheapest Cialis Onlinecom
Viagra Use In Women
Cialis Soft Tabs Guaranteed Overnight Delivery
Generic Name For Viagra
Nitric Oxide Viagra
Viagra Local Pickup
Personal Experience Using Viagra
Prescription Or Not Viagra
Viagra Pharmacy Stop
Half Price Viagra
Vaginal Viagra Suppositories Side Effects
Viagra Find Edinburgh Site Born
Where To Buy Viagra From
Cialis Vs Levitra
Low Cialis Cost
Cheap No Prescription Cialis
Generic Meltabs Viagra
Cheapest Viagra On The Internet
Find Viagra Free Sites Online Computer
Pumpkin Pie Viagra
Biochemical Reaction Of Viagra
Men Taking Cialis And Ambien
Generic Viagra Cialis Levitra Buy Cheap
Cialis By Fedex
Viagra For Female
$99 Viagra Free Consultations Now
Viagra Common Amino Acid Supplement
Free Viagra Samples Online
Cialis Premature Ejaculation
Cheap Mexico Viagra
Cialis Or Viagra Which Is Better
Viagra Penis
Acheter Cialis
Cialis Soft Gels
Viagra Generic Best One
Find Local Charles Linskaill Search Viagra
Baby Saved By Viagra Lewis Goodfellow
Cialis Malaysia
Buy Generic Cialis Softtabs Cheap
Sales Uk Viagra
Cheap Herbal Viagra Viagra
Bush Buy Porn Viagra
Cialis And Long Term Effects
Cialis Product
Can Viagra Be Taken With Ranitidine
Viagra And Heart Medicines
Buy Cialis Domain Online Tripod Com
Buy Form Generic Viagra
Questions And Answers For Cialis Tadalafil
Decongestant With Cialis
Instrumentation Sp Cialis E
Free Trial Of Viagra
Query Viagra
Cheapest Viagra Overnight
Cialis Works Better
Buy Viagra Alternative
Canadian Pharmacy Cialis Deals
Discount Discount Online Viagra Viagra Viagra
On Line Pharmacy Viagra
Viagra For Plants
Which Is Better Cialis Or Viagra
Viagra And Other Natural Erectile Aids
Viagra Cialis And Levitra
Viagra Dangers
Filmy Viagra
Viagra News And Viagra News
Cialis Erection Pics
Viagra And Fraternities
Viagra Herbal Alternatives
Online Pharmacy Viagra Cialis Levitra Manufactures
Cialis Multiple Attempts
Take Cialis And Viagra Together
Buying Viagra Online
Lily Lcos Cialis
Free Trial Of Generic Viagra
Cialis Pricing
Cheap Cialis India
Sale Of Viagra
Viagra Premature Ejactulation
Viagra Uk Online
Can Cialis Take Woman
Viagra For Sale In Uk
Q Viagra Btng Search Meta
Actress Viagra Sports Show Tape Commercial
Viagra Cailis
Mode D’emploi Viagra
Best Source For Uk Viagra Sales
Cialis And Levitra
Cialis Online Get Cialis Cheapest
Free Viagra Without A Prescription
Females On Viagra
Buy Cialis Mail Online
Sites Computer Viagra Edinburgh Pages
Cialis Y La Respiracion
Find Search Edinburgh Viagra Phentermine
Impotence Drug Cialis Pills
Jack Nicholson Viagra
Viagra And Naion
Womans Answer To Viagra
Cheapest Generic Viagra Caverta Veega
Viagra Amp The Red Meat Connection
Prescription Viagra Online
Cut Cialis 20mg
Pharmaceutical Side Effects Viagra
Kidney Transplant Viagra
Order Viagra Here
Disease Viagra Heart
Pfizer Viagra Discount
Free Sample Viagra Vs Cialis
Natural Sources Viagra
Keyword Order Viagra Online
Viagra Tablet
Viagra Consequinses
Adverse Side Effects Cialis
What Is Better Viagra Or Levitra
Drug Viagra Zenegra
Edinburgh Uk Viagra Tid News Moo
Healthy Herbal Viagra
Viagra Non Prescription Deal Sale
Referers Viagra
Silagra Generic Viagra Silagra Cumwithuscom
Generic Cialis W Master Card
Viagra Drug Test
Buy P Viagra
What Is Cialis Soft
Cialis Top Value
Viagra In The Water
Cheap Cialis In Uk
Safe Generic Cialis
Viagra And Atenolol
Phentermine Tramadol Viagra
Viagra Dosage And Cost
Fda Approved Generic Viagra Sildenafil Citrate
Cialis And Alchohol
Cialis 5mg
Compare Cialis
Free Samples Of Cialis
Herbal Cialis Alternative
Viagra Cialis No Prescription Required
Order Zenegra Viagra
Muslims And Viagra
Is Viagra Better Than Levitra
Xanax Viagra Diazepam
Viagra Cialis Comparison
Viagra Health Insurance Coverage
Tadalafil Cialis From India
Generic Cialis Double
Tabs Viagra
Mixing Effexor With Cialis
Side Effects Of Viagra Women
Picture Viagra Pill
Viagra Otc Edinburgh Site Born Find
Viagra Brazil
Cialis Buy Cialis Generic Cialis
Best Generic Cialis Pills Price
Uk Cialis Sales
Generic Cialis Pharmaceutical Manufacturer
Natural Viagra
Cialis Patient Assistance Program
Buy Viagra Xanax
Compare Levetria And Viagra
Viagra Plotters Chance Downfall Bbc News
Viagra On Line Pharmacy
Cialis And Levitra Viagra Online Manufactures
Viagra Discussion Board
Viagra Pages Edinburgh Pregnant Cowper
Generic Viagra Quality
Cialis Liver Disease
Viagra Commercials Wild Thing
Health Viagra Viagra Woman Woman
Buy Cialis Now
Natural Viagra Natural Male Enhancement
Online Online Pharmacy Pharmacy Viagra Vicodin
Viagra Suppositories Ivf
Cialis Sside Effects
Viagra Kamagra Uk
Viagra In Boise
Viagra Viagra A A Target Blank
Viagra And Long Term Effects
Viagra Cialis Levitra Comparisons
Is Cialis A Controlled Substance
Cialis Photo
Generex Viagra
Hiv Drugs And Interactions With Cialis
Singapore Cailis Viagra
Dali Viagra
Viagra Sales
Find Viagra Free Sites Edinburgh Computer
Compare Levitra To Viagra
Viagra Problems
Songs About Viagra
Cialis Prescribing Information
Buy Viagra Online In
Viagra Confidential Fast Prescriptions Online
Herbal Online Sale Viagra Viagra
Cialis Britain
Nexium Cialis
Viagra Levitra Cialis Ads
Interaction Between Viagra And Beta Blockers
Viagra Use Reports
Viagra Precautions
Followup Generic Post Viagra
Viagra Levitra Cialis Pharmacist Prescription Drug
Cheap Generic 50 Mg Viagra
Viagra Generic Discount
Cialis Dosing Information
Tadalafil Levitra Generic Viagra
Cialis Dysfunction Erectile
Which Works Better Cialis Or Viagra
Avoid Fake Risk Viagra
Cialis Literature
Viagra Blindness
Does Generic Viagra From India Work
Generic Viagra Overnight Delivery
Cialis Online Buy
Safe Viagra
Viagra Shorts
Viagra Test
Vendo Viagra
Viagra Instructions Dosage
Fill Pussy With Viagra
Cialis Tadalafil Cheapest Online
Cialis Br
Generic Cialis Online Pharmacy
Viagra Dizziness
Venetian Las Vegas Effects Viagra
Viagra Drugs Zenegra
Buy Viagra Australian
Whats Better Than Viagra
I Doser Viagra
Avoid Counterfeit Viagra
Geniune Cialis No Prescription
Odb Plan Viagra
Viagra Cocaine Died
Prices Cialis
Cialis Order Site
Can You Take Viagra Everyday
Zenerx Natural Viagra
Drug Insert Viagra
Sofia Viagra
Viagra Galloway
Liquid Viagra Shot Recipe
Viagra Website
Cialis User Groups
Viagra 50mg
Compare Cialis To Levitra
Funny Picture Viagra
Cheep Viagra From Inda
Viagra Low Cos
Viagra Purchase
Buy Viagra Cheap
Tramadol Famvir Allegra Cialis
Viagra Cialis Ricetta
Cialis Pills Discussion
Free Viagra Alternative Sample
Viagra High Blood Pressure
Cialis Generic Viagra
Sites Computer Viagra Find Edinburgh Free
Journal Articles About Viagra
Viagra 100
Viagra Cialis No Prescription Fast
Generic Cialis Available In United States
Safe Maximum Viagra Dosage
Dreampharmaceuticals Order Cialis Online
Cheapest Viagra Prices Uk
Does Cialis Work
Best Viagra Alternative Herbal Supplement Information
Free Mail Viagra
Cgi Net Purchase Site Viagra
Generic Viagra Kamagra Overnight Shipping
Viagra Comercial Model
Soft Cialis Reliable
Viagra Propecia
Cheap Cialis Online
Cialis Cialis Online Online
Generic Cialis Pharmaceutical Manufacturer2c Oklahoma
Free Prescription Online Viagra Canada

Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.
%d bloggers like this: