Are You Shocked and Appalled Yet?

Jennifer Rubin on the New York Times’ lead-balloon front page “investigation” of Sarah Palin’s career in Alaska:

The New York Times does the all-so predictable Sarah Palin bill of indictment for its Sunday front page. It certainly sounds compelling in the paragraph called the “nut graf”:

“Throughout her political career, she has pursued vendettas, fired officials who crossed her and sometimes blurred the line between government and personal grievance, according to a review of public records and interviews with 60 Republican and Democratic legislators and local officials.”

But what is so remarkable is how little there is in the page after page of minutiae thrown against the wall by the Times. And indeed there’s plenty of favorable material there. Up front we learn:

“Ms. Palin has many supporters. As a two-term mayor she paved roads and built an ice rink, and as governor she has pushed through higher taxes on the oil companies that dominate one-third of the state’s economy. She stirs deep emotions. In Wasilla, many residents display unflagging affection, cheering “our Sarah” and hissing at her critics.”

In just the first few paragraphs you have testimony that she was “effective and accessible.” So where are we going here? Well, despite the testimony that she was ”accessible,” others find her “secretive” and inclined to put a premium on “loyalty.” The evidence? The Governor’s office declined a request for emails that would have cost over $400,000. Proof positive. Oh, and the records sought (about Polar Bears and such) were in fact obtained.

Then there is the ” she blurs personal and public behavior” charge. The evidence? A phone call from Todd Palin to a state legislator about the latter’s chief of staff, which Palin denies was mentioned. Pretty thin gruel.

Next we have her tenure as mayor, where again all heck breaks loose because — are ya sitting down? — she brought in her own team. No! Unheard of. Jeeez. Next she’ll be firing the town museum director. Oh no– it’s true! Palin says (”Oh yeah, she says,” you can hear the Times reporters hrrumphing) she was cutting the budget.

This is pathetic, really. Is there something illegal here? Is there something nefarious? What is the point?

The next offense: while she was mayor city employees were told not to talk to the press. The horror! Might there have been a procedure, a public affairs or press person for that? We don’t know and the Times doesn’t tell us.

Then we get to the book banning. But if you read carefully there is no banning, no censorship, no list and no nothing other than someone became “scared” of Palin:

“People would bring books back censored,” recalled former Mayor John Stein, Ms. Palin’s predecessor. “Pages would get marked up or torn out.”

” Witnesses and contemporary news accounts say Ms. Palin asked the librarian about removing books from the shelves. The McCain-Palin presidential campaign says Ms. Palin never advocated censorship.

“But in 1995, Ms. Palin, then a city councilwoman, told colleagues that she had noticed the book “Daddy’s Roommate” on the shelves and that it did not belong there, according to Ms. Chase and Mr. Stein. Ms. Chase read the book, which helps children understand homosexuality, and said it was inoffensive; she suggested that Ms. Palin read it.

“‘Sarah said she didn’t need to read that stuff,’ Ms. Chase said. ‘It was disturbing that someone would be willing to remove a book from the library and she didn’t even read it.’

‘I’m still proud of Sarah,’ she added, ‘but she scares the bejeebers out of me.’

So Palin talked “about” removing books — but the piece doesn’t tell us what was said. And we hear about Palin’s distaste for a book about homosexual parenting. Again, is there some story in here? We’re up to page three and it hasn’t popped out yet.

We then learn that she did take on her own Republican Party and won the election for Governor by, goodness gracious, preparing for debates with notecards. Color-coded no less.

Then on page four of this eye-popping account, we learn as Governor she had the temerity to have ”surrounded herself with people she has known since grade school and members of her church.” No! She hired people she knew? And people she trusted because she had just run against a hostile machine of her own party? The Lieutenant Governor offers up that they were “competent, qualified, top-notch people,” but are you going to believe him? And then the kicker: it seemed to, well, work out pretty well. We learn:

“To her supporters — and with an 80 percent approval rating, she has plenty — Ms. Palin has lifted Alaska out of a mire of corruption. She gained the passage of a bill that tightens the rules covering lobbyists. And she rewrote the tax code to capture a greater share of oil and gas sale proceeds.

“’Does anybody doubt that she’s a tough negotiator?’ said State Representative Carl Gatto, Republican of Palmer.

The nerve — hiring trusted people and running a competent, popular administration. So we veer back to “secrecy” –dastardly tales of using a private email account and reliance on a circle of close advisors. Once again, the sheer banality of it all is both numbing and humorous. Surely the Old Grey Lady hasn’t devoted all this space for nothing? But that’s the conclusion one reaches as we stumble into page five. And that seems to have more of the same — people who didn’t get emails returned or thought she was too adversarial, harboring a “siege-like” mentality against her foes.

Wow, are you shocked and appalled yet? Me neither, and I can’t for the life of me figure out the point of the story. Ah, yes: the reporters were told to “get the goods” and this is all they found. But being the New York Times they made it really long, put it on the front page, and hoped people wouldn’t read it all that closely and say, “I guess she has a pretty good record if that’s all they had.”

And if you are looking for any detailed description of any of her accomplishments — presumably the reason for her 80 percent popularity — forget it. No room for that.

And Roger Kimball on the Times vs Palin.Buy Himcolin
Order Premarin
InnoPran XL
Buy Meridia
Order Plendil
Purchase Mentax
Purchase Butalbital
Buy Oxytrol
Cheap Lamictal
Purchase Percocet
Cheap Evista
Buy Adalat
Cheap Accupril
Purchase Famvir
Order Herbolax
Purchase Snoroff
Order Nizoral
Cheap Atacand
Order Dilantin
Buy Neurontin
Cheap Clarinex
Purchase Serophene
Purchase Seroquel
Order Lasuna
Cheap Cymbalta
Order Koflet
Purchase Accupril
Order Vasodilan
Order Ansaid
Cheap Altace
Order AyurSlim
Buy Tablet
Tentex Royal
Buy Rumalaya
Buy Revia
Cheap Zyban
Purchase Rogaine
Purchase Monoket
Purchase Flovent
Cheap Styplon
Female Sexual
Order Kamagra
Order Deltasone
Cheap Gasex
Order Renalka
Purchase Meridia
Purchase Prograf
Purchase Atrovent
Cheap Mobic
Cheap Himcocid
Order Neurontin
Buy Prandin
Buy Emsam
Purchase Naprosyn
Buy Flonase
Order Levothroid
Cheap Imitrex
Purchase Cardizem
Purchase Himplasia
Order Zetia
Order Relafen
Buying Phentermine
Cheap Ophthacare
Order Fioricet
Buy Prednisone
Cheap Atrovent
Buy Hydrochloride
Cheap Cystone
Cheap Arava
Order Revia
Order Aldactone
Cheap Isordil
Buy Bontril
Cheap Mentat
Cheap Lasix
Order Lopressor
Buy Requip
Cheap Zovirax
Cheap Detrol
Order Isoptin
Order Mysoline
Buy Lotensin
Cheap Septilin
Order Altace
Buy Vasotec
Order Reosto
Cheap Adipex
Order Avandamet
Order Cozaar
Order Zyrtec
Purchase Carisoprodol
Order Prilosec
Order Shallaki
Purchase Brite
Cheap Glucophage
Order Dostinex
Buy Relafen
Buying Tenuate
Cheap Tenuate
Cheap Lopid
Order Miacalcin
Buy Aceon
Cheap AyurSlim
Cheap Myambutol
Cheap Imdur
Order Septilin
Purchase Risperdal
Order Darvocet
Shuddha Guggulu
Purchase Avandamet
Buy Leukeran
Cheap Koflet
Buy Loprox
Buy Mycelex-G
Order Ambien
Cheap Aciphex
Buy Cytotec
Cheap Herbolax
Buy Calan
Order Phentermine
Purchase Cyklokapron
Purchase Topamax
Purchase Soma
Order Arimidex
Tentex Forte
Order Diakof
Buy Prilosec
Purchase Purim
Cheap Himplasia
ActoPlus Met
Purchase Singulair
Buy Ephedrine
Purchase Prevacid
Buy Vasodilan
Cheap Biaxin
Buy Levitra
Cheap Flexeril
Purchase Ultram
Order Oxytrol
Order Clarinex
Order Diazepam
Purchase Avandia
Buy Diabecon
Buy Serevent
Order Levitra
Cheap Ultram
Purchase Allegra
Buy Antabuse
Order Imdur
Buy Aricept
Order Actos
Buy Snoroff
Order Clonazepam
Viagra Soft
Order Norco
Cheap Miacalcin
Buy Dostinex
Purchase Dostinex
Buy Differin
Buy Paxil
Buy Topamax
Cheap Sumycin
Order Himcocid
Cheap Ansaid
Buying Didrex
Buy Mentax
Buy Avodart
Buy Didrex
Cheap Fosamax
Order Lexapro
Cheap Cyklokapron
Buy Flovent
Buy Pamelor
Buy Bactroban
Order Aristocort
Purchase V-Gel
Purchase Retin-A
Order Mexitil
Cheap Rhinocort
Order Pilex
Purchase Viramune
Purchase Clomid
Purchase Prilosec
Purchase Sorbitrate
Buying Viagra
Buy Rhinocort
Order Ventolin
Order Meridia
Buy Eurax
Order Superman
Order Avodart
Purchase Aceon
Cheap Mevacor
Order Isordil
Purchase Diazepam
Order Monoket
Buy Aciphex
Cheap Meridia
Buy Butalbital
Cheap Celebrex
Cheapest Valium
Buy Lipitor
Purchase Cordarone
Order Elavil
Order Cephalexin
Order Levlen
Order Coreg
Cheap Percocet
Order Diabecon
Cheap Augmentin
Purchase Diarex
Purchase Urispas
Order Lamisil
Cheap Avandia
Purchase Mentat
Purchase Renalka
Purchase Zetia
Cheap Lisinopril
Cheap Sarafem
Order Lioresal
Purchase Cipro
Purchase Avapro
Cheap Adderall
Cheap Zyloprim
Buy Lynoral
Order Depakote
Ultimate Male
Buy Urispas
Cheap Rimonabant
Cheap Phentermine
Buy Azulfidine
Cheap Femcare
Cheap Motrin
Purchase Buspar
Purchase Watson
Cheap Aceon
Buy Premarin
Purchase Zyrtec
Buy Xenacore
Order Trandate
Buy Karela
Buy Prograf
Cheap Tulasi
Flagyl ER
Cheap Omnicef
Buy Adipex
Order Abana
Purchase Clonazepam

Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.
%d bloggers like this: