World War II: Prime Target of the Historical-Revision Industry

The Wall Street Journal’s invaluable Dorothy Rabinowitz reviews yet another attempt, this time on taxpayer supported PBS, to promote pacifism by rejecting World War II as a triumph over evil:

Early in “The War of the World” — PBS’s very own entry into the lists of revisionist tracts about World War II now clamoring for attention — historian Niall Ferguson appears on camera to tell how he had been deceived about that war, and the one before it as well. He had been a schoolboy, and they had taught him wrong — and what was most wrong, the rest of this three-part work (beginning Monday, 10-11 p.m. EDT, check local listings) sets out to show, was any notion that in those wars the forces of good had triumphed over those of evil.

Mr. Ferguson’s series (he is its writer and presenter) concerns itself with both World Wars and the conflicts since, but the throbbing heart of this enterprise is impossible to miss — namely, its argument that the Allies who had brought about the end of the Nazis and Nazism, and of Imperial Japan, were only marginally better, morally speaking, than the foes they had defeated. That throb is there in the publicity announcement — always a reliable indicator of what a program’s producers consider their most important big idea. The first line of the release delivers the message: “World War II, we have been told all our lives, was our greatest triumph. . . .” Like Niall Ferguson as a schoolboy, we had all, in short, been misled. Till now.

If any of this sounds familiar, that’s because it is just that. Revisionist history of all kinds is a hot field, never more so than today. At least two books of recent vintage claim that Americans have been misled about the world-famous crusader of the 1950s, the late, notorious Sen. Joe McCarthy. The Wisconsin senator — whose ill-famed reputation was nothing if not well earned — was, we are now informed, one of America’s great heroes.

But it is World War II that is, as it long has been, the prime target of the historical-revision industry. Today, on the right, we have Pat Buchanan’s “Churchill, Hitler, and the Unnecessary War.” It portrays Winston Churchill as a warmonger who turned a deaf ear to Adolf Hitler — a much misunderstood man, in Mr. Buchanan’s view — and to all evidence of Hitler’s wish to be friends. That title gets straight to the point. Mr. Buchanan’s book, enthusiastically touted by Sean Hannity, is on the best-seller list now. Meanwhile, a political world or so away on PBS, we have Mr. Ferguson.

And there is plenty of him. We can marvel not only at the number and kind of claimed fallacies Mr. Ferguson is busy setting right here, but also at the amount of travel that has put him, and his cameras, on location in every corner of the globe. The documentary is rich in background scenes — a good thing — and Mr. Ferguson is physically at the center of every last one of them. Not such a good thing. Here he is on the banks of the Volga, and there, looming out at us from a room housing the Gulag’s secret archives. We find him lunching in the sun, near Hitler’s Berghof in Bavaria, where, he confides, he feels a bit strange — eating and all. Inevitably, he arrives at Auschwitz, heart of darkness, to ask how it all came to be.

The answer quickly circles back to the main point — that the Allies could not be credited with any triumph over evil.

Russian troops had liberated Auschwitz, yes, but we’re reminded that Stalin had imprisoned and murdered millions. Does this mean the liberation of Auschwitz was nothing? A good question with no answer. Mr. Ferguson is content to have delivered another in his long stream of accusatory ironies and contradictions, all in support of the claim that the morally tainted Allied armies should not be credited as liberators.

The Americans and British had adopted the totalitarian techniques of their foes, Mr. Ferguson contends in a series of arguments ranging from the strange to the simply inflated. Japanese combatants kept fighting to the very end, he explains, because they feared the cruelty of their American captors. Undoubtedly some American troops were guilty of killing Japanese prisoners. In this film’s version of events, the slaughter was wholesale. By way of support Mr. Ferguson summons testimony from Charles Lindbergh — pro-Nazi icon of American isolationists. He proceeds to reminds us that Lindbergh had complained, in the 1940s, that Americans thought nothing of killing Japanese prisoners. Noteworthy to be sure — the first and last time, perhaps, that the world was privileged to hear Lindbergh express outrage over the commission of atrocities.

The catalog of Mr. Ferguson’s stranger arguments is too long to go into, but here’s a hint — don’t miss the part about Kursk, the greatest of all tank battles. Here the U.S. seems to stand accused of providing material help that made it possible for the Russians to prevail. Were the Germans supposed to win? Mr. Ferguson doesn’t say, but the question hangs in the air — for good reason.

More news by category Topic -: Buy phentermine saturday delivery ohio Tramadol hydrochloride tablets Picture of xanax pills Free shipping cheap phentermine Buying phentermine without prescription Safety of phentermine Pyridium Generic viagra cialis Cialis generic india Pink oval pill 17 xanax identification Buy free phentermine shipping Best price for generic viagra Information about street drugs or xanax bars Ordering viagra Snorting phentermine Hydrocodone overdose Lithium Amiodarone Get online viagra Order viagra prescription Order xanax paying cod Cheap phentermine free shipping Imiquimod Tramadol next day Linkdomain buy online viagra info domain buy onlin Pfizer viagra sperm Vidarabine Cheapest viagra price Prevacid Viagra cialis levitra comparison Dutasteride Lisinopril Thiotepa Female spray viagra Black market phentermine Betamethasone Cialis forums What does xanax look like Loss phentermine story success weight Order xanax overnight Viagra alternative uk Diet online phentermine pill Order xanax cod Mecamylamine Eulexin Cheap hydrocodone Buy cheapest viagra Viagra xenical Phentermine with no prior prescription Xanax in urine Macrodantin Cheap phentermine with online consultation Epivir Buy phentermine epharmacist Ditropan Woman use viagra Cialis erectile dysfunction Xanax withdrawl message boards Viagra online store Atorvastatin Generic ambien Is phentermine addictive Next day delivery on phentermine Buy online viagra Ethanol Natural phentermine Avandamet Xanax long term use Diet page phentermine pill yellow 5 cheap Cheapest secure delivery cialis uk Information medical phentermine Cialis experience Phentermine no perscription Compare ionamin phentermine Viagra cialis levivia dose comparison Noroxin Effects of viagra on women Buy cheap cialis Viagra shelf life Hydroxyurea Phentermine discount no prescription Buy cheap online viagra Dog xanax Online cialis Viagra class action Viagra price Phentermine without prescription and energy pill Hydrocodone cod only Nicoumalone Cheapest viagra Cheap ambien Vicodin without prescription Phentermine prescription online Phentermine snorting Mirtazapine Quazepam Isradipine Buy generic viagra online Xanax look alike Moxifloxacin Viagra experiences Piroxicam Nicorette Free try viagra Sotalol Cash on delivery shipping of phentermine How do i stop taking phentermine Xanax prescriptions Cheapest phentermine 90 day order Niacinamide Phentermine weight loss Phentermine Indocin
Phentermine diet
Purchase tramadol without a prescription
100 phentermine
Order viagra without prescription
Uk viagra supplier
Xanax effect
Generic online phentermine
Luxury hotel rome xanax description
Order phentermine cod online
How to inject xanax pills
Phentermine discount no prescription
Amsterdam holland viagra
Cialis generic viagra
Cialis levitra viagra vs vs
Xanax mexico
Injecting xanax
Viagra pill cutter
Atenolol viagra
Xanax tablets
Hydrocodone bitartrate acetaminophen
Order cialis online
Lowest phentermine prices
Pain medication tramadol
Effects of long term xanax use
Buy cheap phentermine yellow
Does viagra woman
Compare levivia and viagra
Cheap diet online phentermine pill
Levivia compared to viagra
Buy and purchase viagra online
Generic uk viagra
Tramadol cheap overnight inexpensive
Xanax description
Order xanax overnight
Vicodin detox
Does phentermine interact with hydrocodone
Xanax vs klonopin
Buy Cipro
Viagra female sexual inhancement
Xanax grapefruit juice
Liqued viagra
Cheapest place buy viagra online
Cialis side effects
Cialis pills
Phentermine money orders
Hydrocodone cod only
Wholesale phentermine
Phentermine ephedrine
Generic viagra no perscription needed
Phentermine hormone
Generic cialis prices
Lexapro and phentermine
Viagra cialis levitra comparison
Phentermine prozac
Fda approved phentermine
Cheap 37 5 phentermine
Black market costa rica pharmacy phentermine no imprint code
Hydrocodone withdrawal
Viagra vs levivia
Viagra useage
How to discontinue the use of phentermine
Info on meridia
Online phentermine pharmacy best cheapest
Xanax dose
Order vicodin
Viagra experiences
Uk viagra suppliers
Xanax liver damage
Free sample herbal viagra
What do xanax look like
Phentermine and topiramate for weightloss
Tramadol side effects
Order phentermine diet pill
Viagra cialis levitra comparison dosages
Herbal phentermine forum
Phentermine blue 30 mg
Compare cialis levivia viagra
Extra cheap phentermine
Herbal viagra alternatives
Buy xanax
No fax payday loan buy tramadol
Phentermine uses
Hydrocodone query
Phentermine pharmacy online consultation
Buy phentermine epharmacist
No prescription viagra
Discount drug phentermine
Xanax addiction
Side effects of viagra
Free shipping cheap phentermine
Xanax and grapefruit
Fill viagra prescription
Phentermine 37.5 cheap
Phentermine online cod
Cash on delivery for phentermine
Viagra retail discount
Interstitial cystitis xanax
Alternative viagra
Natural viagra for woman

Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.
%d bloggers like this: